bugi'm so tempted to give it a 5 even though it's the arc of missed opportunities and failed plotlines, just for how formative it was. would be so much better if the follow up arc concluded anything but the seat of your pants writing style is incredibly prominent with this one. meanders a lot. still, judging it by later books isn't entirely fair. in my opinion it has the best main characters - yes, including lionblaze. his early appearances are just good. of course hollyleaf and jayfeather take two of the spots for my favorite characters in wc (of all time...?). i could write essays of character analysis on the three. eclipse and sunrise were so awesome for obvious reasons. weak plot beyond that but the characters make it hold up for me. my 4/5 is definitely nostalgia talking but i can admit that. it was my favorite arc as a kid. sadly tbc doesn't have a wikipedia article but it takes the #1 spot now if you were curious. which checks out for sure.
No comments yet
Sign in to comment.